You thought we forgot about these, didn’t you? Well, we did. Kinda. So mea culpa is that we actually did an season premiere episode talking and arguing about these and the recordings didn’t cooperate and were accidentally poo. Not the show quality, that’s always poo. But we lost some voices and it just wasn’t going to work. So with our apologies, please peruse on what we decided on that night, the 2024 Finisher Awards!
| Category | Winner |
| Breakout of the Year | Joe Hendry (unanimous) |
| Moment of the Year | Cody Rhodes finishes the story at Wrestlemania XL |
| Show of the Year | Wrestlemania XL |
| Tag Team of the Year | Sting & Darby Allin |
| Women’s Feud of the Year | Rhea Ripley vs. Liv Morgan |
| Men’s Feud of the Year | CM Punk vs. Drew McIntyre |
| Women’s Wrestler of the Year | Toni Storm |
| Men’s Wrestler of the Year | Will Ospreay |
| Women’s Match of the Year | AEW TBS Championship: Mercedes Mone (c) vs. Kris Statlander – Worlds End, Dec. 28 |
| Men’s Match of the Year | 5-Way Tie Will Ospreay vs. Brian Danielson -Dynasty, April 21 Hell in a Cell Match: CM Punk vs. Drew McIntyre – Bad Blood, Oct. 5 Will Ospreay vs. Konosuke Takeshita – Revolution, March 3 Mike Bailey vs. Vikingo – Bound for Glory, Oct. 26 Brian Danielson vs. Zack Sabre Jr. – The New Beginning in Osaka, Feb. 11 |
The Finisher 